THE GAME. THE STORIES. THE WHY.
Independent football coverage●Our standards
EXPLOREPower rankingsLeague leadersTeam statsInjuriesTransactionsShortsRivalriesRecordsBye weeksEVENTSSuper BowlPro BowlCombineDraftPlayoffsWeb StoriesALL FOOTBALL. ALL IN.
WEEK 10
Find your next read

Search whynfl

Go deeper on the game you love.

News

Three weekend 2027 mocks: Drew Mestemaker goes second, third or fourth, two of them put five quarterbacks in Round 1, and one sends Jalen Hurts to the Browns

5 min read Comments
Share ↗
WhatsApp Facebook X
Saved articles

Your reading list is saved on this browser.

Your reaction

Cameron Sheath, Chris Gregory and Cody Williams all send Jeremiah Smith to the Chargers first, then split on Drew Mestemaker, who goes second, third or fourth. Gregory adds three trades, including Jalen Hurts to Cleveland, and Daniel Jeremiah calls Oklahoma State's quarterback the best prospect at the position.

w.
WhyNFL Sports DeskPublished
Drew Mestemaker, wearing No. 11 for North Texas, drops back to pass at Rice
Drew Mestemaker (No. 11) drops back for North Texas at Rice in November 2025, before his move to Oklahoma State. Photo by 2C2K Photography, resized.

Three new 2027 mock drafts came out over the weekend, and all three still start with Ohio State receiver Jeremiah Smith going first to the winless Los Angeles Chargers. After that they split on Oklahoma State quarterback Drew Mestemaker, who goes second, third or fourth, and on how many quarterbacks belong in the first round.

Cameron Sheath and Chris Gregory each put five quarterbacks in Round 1, but not the same five. Cody Williams projected only the top 10 picks after Sunday’s afternoon games, using the updated draft order, and has three quarterbacks in it. Gregory also adds trades, and in his mock the Jets move up to No. 2 for Mestemaker and the Eagles trade Jalen Hurts to the Browns.

The top 10 in all three

PickCameron SheathChris Gregory (with trades)Cody Williams (after Sunday)
1Chargers: Jeremiah Smith, WRChargers: Jeremiah Smith, WRChargers: Jeremiah Smith, WR
2Titans: Colin Simmons, EDGEJets (trade): Drew Mestemaker, QBTitans: Colin Simmons, EDGE
3Dolphins: Jordan Seaton, OTDolphins: CJ Carr, QBDolphins: Drew Mestemaker, QB
4Jets (from Colts): Drew Mestemaker, QBTitans (trade): Colin Simmons, EDGEJets: CJ Carr, QB
5Eagles: Dylan Stewart, EDGEEagles: Darian Mensah, QBEagles: Jordan Seaton, OT
6Jets: Will Echoles, DTTitans (trade): Leonard Moore, CBJets (from Colts): Leonard Moore, CB
7Buccaneers: Xavier Gilliam, DTCommanders: Charlie Becker, WRCardinals: Arch Manning, QB
8Cardinals: Arch Manning, QBCardinals: Dante Moore, QBFalcons: Zereoue Williams, OT
9Falcons: Darian Mensah, QBBuccaneers: Trinidad Chambliss, QBTexans: Trevor Goosby, OT
10Texans: Trevor Goosby, OTFalcons: Dylan Stewart, EDGEBuccaneers: Dylan Stewart, EDGE

Sheath’s mock was built on a simulator that updates the order after every game, and Williams used the order after Sunday’s games. Gregory says his order uses current standings and strength of schedule, so some teams, like the Cardinals, pick later than they might in the end. Monday night’s Chargers game at Baltimore can still change the top of the order.

Where the quarterbacks go

QuarterbackSchoolSheathGregoryWilliams (top 10 only)
Drew MestemakerOklahoma State4, Jets2, Jets (trade)3, Dolphins
CJ CarrNotre Dame16, Browns3, Dolphins4, Jets
Arch ManningTexas8, CardinalsBack to school7, Cardinals
Darian MensahMiami9, Falcons5, EaglesNot in top 10
Dante MooreOregon26, Steelers8, CardinalsNot in top 10
Trinidad ChamblissOle MissNot in Round 19, BuccaneersNot in top 10

Sheath has Miami take LSU tackle Jordan Seaton third with Mestemaker still on the board. He wrote that it “would require cool heads from Miami’s decision-makers, with so many quarterbacks on the board,” and give Malik Willis a fair shot at the job. The Jets take Mestemaker one pick later. “All of this year’s QBs have time to move up draft boards before April, but I’m going with Drew Mestemaker in this mock,” Sheath wrote. He called Mensah to Atlanta at No. 9 “probably the hottest take of this mock.”

Williams sends Mestemaker to Miami, writing that “the tools with Mestemaker will make you drool” and that he “has a howitzer attached at the shoulder.” He also said Mestemaker, Carr and Manning could all return to school. On Manning, he wrote that “being a hater of the Texas quarterback has become so in-vogue these days that we’re being told lies.”

A full first-round 2027 mock built on the draft order after Week 10, posted Monday.

Gregory’s trades

Gregory has three trades in his first round. The Jets send Nos. 4 and 6 to Tennessee to move up to No. 2 for Mestemaker, who he says could sit behind Geno Smith for eight weeks. The Titans use the two picks on Texas edge rusher Colin Simmons and Notre Dame cornerback Leonard Moore.

The Eagles take Mensah fifth and then trade Hurts to Cleveland. In return, Philadelphia gets picks 16 and 18 and uses them on Ole Miss defensive tackle Will Echoles and Seaton. The Browns get Hurts and a 2028 second-round pick. Gregory has Manning, Arizona State’s Sam Leavitt and South Carolina’s LaNorris Sellers all going back to school, and Ole Miss’s Chambliss goes ninth to Tampa Bay.

TradeTeamGets
1JetsNo. 2 (Drew Mestemaker) and a late first-round pick
1TitansNos. 4 and 6 (Colin Simmons, Leonard Moore)
2EaglesNos. 16 and 18 (Will Echoles, Jordan Seaton)
2BrownsJalen Hurts and a 2028 second-round pick

Jeremiah: the best quarterback prospect is at Oklahoma State

Daniel Jeremiah has not yet put out his first top 50 of the season, but he made his quarterback view clear in a recent conversation with Peter Schrager about the Jets. “I don’t think it’s a secret here. The Jets need a long-term [solution at] quarterback, and in my opinion, and everyone I talked to so far in the process around the league, the best quarterback in college football, the best prospect, in this draft at that position, is at Oklahoma State,” Jeremiah said.

The Jets have three first-round picks, their own, the Colts’ and the Cowboys’. After Sunday’s 31-12 loss to Buffalo, they are 2-8, and in Williams’ order they pick fourth, sixth and 13th. Scouts from both New York teams were at Mestemaker’s 52-27 loss to Texas Tech on Saturday, the second straight week the Jets watched him in person.

Highlights of Texas Tech at Oklahoma State, Saturday, November 14, 2026.

Mestemaker hurt his throwing shoulder on Oklahoma State’s first drive in that game and played through what he called a stinger, as we covered in Saturday’s quarterback roundup. Coach Eric Morris said the team would re-evaluate him on Monday, and there was no update by Monday morning in Stillwater. Oklahoma State plays at Arizona State on Saturday.

The mocks line up with the latest rankings. Dane Brugler’s midseason top 50 has Mestemaker second overall, and Rob Rang’s quarterback rankings moved him to No. 1 last week. Last week’s mocks, in the first three and three more, had Mestemaker going third or fourth in all six. For Chambliss’ latest game, see Ole Miss’s loss at Oklahoma, and for how the picks moved at the deadline, see our 2027 draft order tracker.

The why matters.

See something that needs a second look? Read our corrections policy.

Join the conversation

Use a name or stay anonymous. No account or email required. Comments are reviewed before appearing.

Up to 3,000 characters

No published comments yet. Start the conversation.