THE GAME. THE STORIES. THE WHY.
Independent football coverage●Our standards
EXPLOREPower rankingsLeague leadersTeam statsInjuriesTransactionsShortsRivalriesRecordsBye weeksEVENTSSuper BowlPro BowlCombineDraftPlayoffsWeb StoriesALL FOOTBALL. ALL IN.
WEEK 10
Find your next read

Search whynfl

Go deeper on the game you love.

News

Rob Rang’s top 2027 quarterbacks on Saturday: Arch Manning throws three interceptions and then beats LSU with 3 seconds left, Drew Mestemaker plays through a stinger in a 52-27 loss

5 min read Comments
Share ↗
WhatsApp Facebook X
Saved articles

Your reading list is saved on this browser.

Your reaction

Arch Manning threw three interceptions and then a 4-yard touchdown with 3 seconds left in Texas' 22-21 win at LSU, while Drew Mestemaker hurt his throwing shoulder on the first drive of Oklahoma State's 52-27 loss to Texas Tech. How Rob Rang's top 2027 quarterbacks did on Saturday.

w.
WhyNFL Sports DeskPublished
Texas quarterback Arch Manning drops back to pass at Darrell K Royal-Texas Memorial Stadium
Arch Manning drops back for Texas against UTSA in September 2024. Photo by Johntex, CC-BY-SA-4.0, resized.

The top two quarterbacks in Rob Rang’s updated 2027 rankings played on Saturday night, and neither had the game scouts were hoping for. Texas’ Arch Manning, Rang’s No. 2, threw three interceptions at LSU and then won the game with a 4-yard touchdown pass with 3 seconds left. Oklahoma State’s Drew Mestemaker, Rang’s No. 1, hurt his throwing shoulder on the first drive against Texas Tech and played through it in a 52-27 loss.

Elsewhere in the class, Miami’s Darian Mensah threw for 382 yards against his old team, Notre Dame’s CJ Carr had an efficient day in a blowout, USC’s Jayden Maiava threw three interceptions at Indiana, and South Carolina’s LaNorris Sellers did not play. Ole Miss’ Trinidad Chambliss has not played yet: his game at Oklahoma was moved to Sunday at noon Central after Friday’s FAA ground stop disrupted the Rebels’ travel.

Manning: three interceptions, then the winning drive

No. 8 Texas beat No. 24 LSU 22-21 at Tiger Stadium, its first win in Death Valley since 1952. Manning finished 19 of 35 for 174 yards, one touchdown and three interceptions, was sacked four times and ran 12 times for 35 yards and a touchdown, a 1-yard keeper on the opening drive. Texas trailed 21-10 in the third quarter.

The Longhorns got the ball back at their own 42 with 2:19 left, down 21-16. Manning completed six of eight passes for 51 yards on the 12-play, 58-yard drive, converted three third downs, one with a 5-yard pass and two with his legs, and found running back Raleek Brown on the left sideline for the winning score. The two-point try failed. “That’s what it’s all about: Death Valley at night, two-minute drive, let’s go,” Manning said after the game.

Arch Manning’s 4-yard touchdown pass to Raleek Brown with 3 seconds left at LSU.

Rang moved Manning up to second on Thursday, higher than Mel Kiper Jr., Brugler or Jordan Reid have him. Dane Brugler has him 25th overall in his midseason top 50, behind four other quarterbacks. Saturday gave both sides something: the three interceptions, two of them to LSU safety Ty Benefield, and the drive at the end.

Mestemaker: a stinger on the first drive

Mestemaker went 27 of 42 for 277 yards, one touchdown and two interceptions. Oklahoma State says his school-record streak of eight straight 300-yard games, the longest active streak in FBS, ended, though he has now passed for at least 200 yards in 25 straight games. Texas Tech returned the opening kickoff 97 yards for a touchdown and led 21-0 after one quarter.

He landed on his throwing shoulder on the opening drive. “I was pretty upset honestly,” Mestemaker said. “Like first drive, and throwing shoulder.” He called it “just a stinger” and would not use it as an excuse: “At the end of the day, like I’m not going to blame it on that. Like there were multiple plays that I could have made the throw or the decision better.” He attempted only one pass of 20 or more yards, an incompletion. Coach Eric Morris said the team will reevaluate him on Monday.

Drew Mestemaker after Oklahoma State’s 52-27 loss to Texas Tech on Nov. 14.

Reid, who has Mestemaker in his updated top 50, pointed to the same concern Rang raised on Thursday, when he noted that 14 of Mestemaker’s 17 charted turnover-worthy plays this season came on the road.

How Rang’s top quarterbacks did on Saturday

Rang rankQuarterbackResultLine
1Drew Mestemaker, Oklahoma StateLost 52-27 to Texas Tech27 of 42, 277 yards, 1 TD, 2 INT
2Arch Manning, TexasWon 22-21 at LSU19 of 35, 174 yards, 1 TD, 3 INT; 1 rushing TD
3Dante Moore, OregonOut for the season (concussion)Did not play
4Trinidad Chambliss, Ole MissAt Oklahoma, moved to SundayNot yet played
5CJ Carr, Notre DameWon 41-7 vs. Boston College20 of 28, 217 yards, 2 TD, 1 INT
6Darian Mensah, MiamiWon 36-25 vs. Duke30 of 41, 382 yards, 1 TD, 0 INT
7LaNorris Sellers, South CarolinaLost 34-6 at ArkansasDid not play
8Jayden Maiava, USCLost 27-13 at Indiana26 of 42, 311 yards, 1 TD, 3 INT
12Sam Leavitt, LSULost 22-21 to Texas27 of 37, 244 yards, 2 TD, 3 INT

Mensah’s 382 yards came against Duke, where he played before transferring to Miami; his longest completion was a 63-yard touchdown pass in the third quarter. Carr threw touchdown passes of 26 yards to Micah Gilbert and 13 yards to Jordan Faison as Notre Dame led by 31 at halftime. Maiava’s third interception came on a fourth-and-13 with 2:36 left, and USC scored one touchdown in five red-zone trips. Brugler’s No. 5 overall prospect, Indiana receiver Charlie Becker, caught three passes for 75 yards in that game, including a 42-yard touchdown that made it 27-13.

The safeties who had the best night in Baton Rouge

Brugler wrote during the game that nine prospects in Texas-LSU appear in his top 50. The best night belonged to Texas safety Jelani McDonald, No. 30 on that board, who intercepted Leavitt three times, two of them in the end zone, and had 11 tackles. Texas says he is the first Longhorn with three interceptions in a game since Aaron Humphrey in 1997. Benefield, No. 38 on Brugler’s board, intercepted Manning twice. Brugler calls them his top two senior safeties in the class.

Other top-50 names in the game included Texas edge rusher Colin Simmons (No. 3), LSU left tackle Jordan Seaton (No. 8) and LSU receiver Jackson Harris (No. 33), who caught eight passes for 64 yards and both LSU touchdowns. Leavitt, 12th on Rang’s list, completed 27 of 37 passes but threw all three of his interceptions to McDonald. “Very hard to take Sam Leavitt seriously,” Brugler wrote.

Chambliss, Rang’s former No. 1 quarterback, and Oklahoma’s John Mateer, Rang’s No. 10, meet in Norman on Sunday. For where the rest of the class stands, see Mel Kiper Jr.’s updated big board, the latest post-deadline mock drafts and Jeremiah Smith’s Big Ten record on Saturday.

The why matters.

See something that needs a second look? Read our corrections policy.

Join the conversation

Use a name or stay anonymous. No account or email required. Comments are reviewed before appearing.

Up to 3,000 characters

No published comments yet. Start the conversation.