
Forty-one years ago this Wednesday, on Monday night, November 18, 1985, Joe Theismann took a pitch back from John Riggins at RFK Stadium and never threw another pass in the NFL. Lawrence Taylor hit him from behind, Gary Reasons came over the top, and Theismann’s right leg broke under the pile. He was 36, the oldest starting quarterback in the league, and had played in 163 consecutive games for Washington.
The game kept going, and it turned into one of the stranger wins of the Joe Gibbs era. Jay Schroeder, a second-year backup who had thrown eight passes in his career, came off the bench, Steve Cox recovered two onside kicks and threw a pass on a fake punt, and Washington, then called the Redskins, came from behind to beat the first-place Giants 23-21.
A must-win night for a 5-5 team
Washington came in 5-5, with Theismann rated the NFC’s second-lowest passer, two years after he had been named the league’s MVP. Gibbs had said during the week that if his team lost, it would take “something great” to reach the playoffs. The Giants were 7-3 and had won four in a row. Washington was also without left tackle Joe Jacoby, so guard Russ Grimm moved outside to protect Theismann’s blind side.
The trick plays started on the first drive. Facing fourth-and-3 at his own 43, Cox, the punter, lobbed an 11-yard pass to rookie safety Raphel Cherry for a first down. Theismann went 6 of 7 on the 64-yard drive and finished it with a 10-yard touchdown pass to tight end Don Warren. The Giants tied it before the end of the first quarter: a pass interference call on Vernon Dean moved them to the Washington 44, and Joe Morris ran 56 yards untouched off left tackle.
The flea-flicker
On the second play of the second quarter, first-and-10 from the Washington 46, Gibbs called a flea-flicker. Theismann handed off to Riggins, who turned and pitched the ball back to him. The Giants did not bite. Taylor reached Theismann from behind before he could throw, Reasons hit him from the front, and as Theismann went down, his right ankle folded under his body. Taylor jumped up and immediately began waving frantically for help.
Theismann was taken off on a stretcher and to Arlington Hospital, where team physician Dr. Charles Jackson operated that night. Both bones of the lower leg, the tibia and fibula, were broken, and the bone came through the skin. “The fracture is right at the boot line,” Jackson said. He estimated Theismann would need six months before he could walk without crutches. Theismann had completed 7 of 10 passes for 50 yards.
Years later Theismann described the moment this way: “My leg snapped like a breadstick. I heard it clearly, it sounded like two muzzled gunshots over my left shoulder.” The replay, shown again and again on the broadcast that night, became one of the most replayed injuries in the sport’s history, and the play later opened Michael Lewis’s book The Blind Side, on why teams pay so much for the tackle who protects a quarterback from the rush he cannot see.
Schroeder’s first throw goes 44 yards
Schroeder, 24, had spent two years in the Toronto Blue Jays’ farm system before choosing football. His first pass went 44 yards to Art Monk at the Giants’ 13. That drive ended badly, when Riggins fumbled on third-and-1 from the 4 and Taylor recovered at the 2, and the half ended 7-7.
Gibbs kept gambling. He opened the second half with a surprise onside kick: Cox dribbled the ball forward and fell on it himself at the Washington 46, far in front of any Giant. On the next play Schroeder threw deep down the right sideline to Monk, who got between Elvis Patterson and Kenny Hill and made a lunging catch at the 4 for a 50-yard gain. Riggins scored from the 1, and Washington led 14-7 with 13:23 left in the third quarter.
Morris answered twice. He went 41 yards around the left side to tie it, and after Perry Williams recovered a George Rogers fumble at the Washington 23, Morris scored from the 8, his third touchdown of the night and a club-record 11th of the season. The Giants led 21-14 with 6:06 left in the third quarter. Morris finished with 118 yards on 17 carries.
Another onside kick, and the winner
Mark Moseley kicked a 28-yard field goal to make it 21-17 with 11:25 to play. Then Gibbs went back to Cox, and the second onside kick of the night was recovered by safety Greg Williams. Schroeder completed three straight passes, the last a 14-yard touchdown to tight end Clint Didier, who took the ball away from Patterson, with 8:21 left. Moseley missed the extra point, which is why the final was 23-21. The rules on that kick are in our extra point and two-point guide.
Phil Simms, sacked four times, completed 9 of 18 passes for 138 yards, and Dean intercepted him with 1:09 left to end it. Schroeder finished 13 of 20 for 221 yards and a touchdown; Monk caught seven passes for 130 yards. Cox’s surprise onside kicks could not happen now: under today’s kickoff rules an onside attempt has to be declared and kicked from its own formation, so there is no surprising anyone, as our kickoff guide explains.
| Qtr | Time | Team | Scoring play | NYG-WAS |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 8:22 | WAS | Don Warren 10-yard pass from Joe Theismann (Mark Moseley kick) | 0-7 |
| 1 | 4:20 | NYG | Joe Morris 56-yard run (Eric Schubert kick) | 7-7 |
| 3 | 13:23 | WAS | John Riggins 1-yard run (Moseley kick), after an onside kick | 7-14 |
| 3 | 11:05 | NYG | Morris 41-yard run (Schubert kick) | 14-14 |
| 3 | 6:06 | NYG | Morris 8-yard run (Schubert kick) | 21-14 |
| 4 | 11:25 | WAS | Moseley 28-yard field goal | 21-17 |
| 4 | 8:21 | WAS | Clint Didier 14-yard pass from Jay Schroeder (kick failed), after an onside kick | 21-23 |
“Dedicated the game to Joe”
“I think we’re alive for another day, for another week anyway,” Gibbs said. “All our guys and all our coaches dedicated the game to Joe.” Of Schroeder he said: “When he came to the sideline, I’ll tell you the man wasn’t even perspiring. I think he’s going to be an unusual guy.”
“Every week you always think it’s going to come now, you’re going to play now,” Schroeder said. “When it finally comes, you don’t want it to come like this, with someone getting hurt.” Bill Parcells gave the credit to the kicking game: “They took three big gambles tonight in their kicking game. Any one of them could have lost them the game. But they executed them and they got it done.”
What came after
Theismann never played again. The bones healed poorly, his right leg ended up shorter than his left, and he retired. He has said many times that Taylor apologized to him and that he never blamed Taylor for doing his job. Schroeder went 4-1 the rest of the way, but Washington finished 10-6 and missed the playoffs, while the Giants, also 10-6, went as a wild card. A year later Schroeder threw for a then-team-record 4,109 yards, made the Pro Bowl and took Washington to the NFC Championship Game, where it lost 17-0 to the Giants.
The date came back 33 years later. On November 18, 2018, Washington quarterback Alex Smith was sacked by Kareem Jackson and J.J. Watt midway through the third quarter against Houston, and his right leg broke the same way, tibia and fibula. Theismann was at the game. “I still have goosebumps,” he said afterward. “I can’t believe it. November 18th is such a horrible day for Redskins quarterbacks.” The score that day was 23-21 as well, this time for the Texans. Unlike Theismann, Smith came back after a long series of surgeries, started again in 2020 and was named Comeback Player of the Year; he was the starter in Washington’s 41-16 Thanksgiving win in Dallas that season.
| November 18, 1985 | November 18, 2018 | |
|---|---|---|
| Quarterback | Joe Theismann, 36 | Alex Smith, 34 |
| Opponent | New York Giants, at RFK Stadium | Houston Texans, at home in Landover |
| Play | Sacked by Lawrence Taylor and Gary Reasons on a flea-flicker | Sacked by Kareem Jackson and J.J. Watt |
| Injury | Broken tibia and fibula, right leg | Broken tibia and fibula, right leg |
| Replacement | Jay Schroeder | Colt McCoy |
| Final | Washington 23, Giants 21 | Texans 23, Washington 21 |
| Afterward | Never played again | Returned in 2020, Comeback Player of the Year |
Washington and the Giants, again
The rivalry is close this season too. Last Thursday night Washington came from behind to beat the Giants 24-21 when Jayden Daniels found Stefon Diggs with 57 seconds left, the same kind of late rally Schroeder led 41 years ago; how that drive came together is in our step-by-step look. The Commanders, now 3-5-1, host the 7-2 Bengals on Monday night, November 23, at 8:15 p.m. ET (3:15 a.m. Tuesday in Cairo). The 5-3-1 Giants play the Jaguars at MetLife Stadium on Sunday.
The scoring plays, clock times and player numbers above come from the official box score of the 1985 game. The quotes are from postgame comments that night, from Theismann’s later recollection and from his comments at the 2018 game.

No published comments yet. Start the conversation.