THE GAME. THE STORIES. THE WHY.
Independent football coverage●Our standards
EXPLOREPower rankingsLeague leadersTeam statsInjuriesTransactionsShortsRivalriesRecordsBye weeksEVENTSSuper BowlPro BowlCombineDraftPlayoffsWeb StoriesALL FOOTBALL. ALL IN.
WEEK 10
Find your next read

Search whynfl

Go deeper on the game you love.

News

After the ground stop: Don Willard referees two games in one day, and the Panthers are flagged a record 17 times and still win in the game reviewed from New York

6 min read Comments
Share ↗
WhatsApp Facebook X
Saved articles

Your reading list is saved on this browser.

Your reaction

Don Willard's crews called 16 accepted penalties in Indianapolis and 12 in Cincinnati on the first two-game day for an NFL referee. In New Orleans, with replay run from New York and a backup referee, the Panthers set a franchise record with 17 penalties for 152 yards and still beat the Saints 20-17.

w.
WhyNFL Sports DeskPublished
NFL officials confer on the field during a game at Lambeau Field
NFL officials confer during the Commanders' game at the Packers on September 11, 2025. Photo by All-Pro Reels (Joe Glorioso), resized.

The NFL got through its ground-stop Sunday. Don Willard became the first official on record to referee two NFL games on the same day, the three backup referees all finished their games, and the one game without a replay official in the building was run from the league’s command center in New York. What stood out on the stat sheets was Carolina: the Panthers were penalized 17 times for 152 yards in New Orleans, the most by any team in a game this season, and still won 20-17.

The crews had been broken up on Saturday after Friday’s nationwide FAA ground stop left officials, who fly commercial, unable to count on getting to their games. The league moved them to games within driving distance of home and gave regular-season games to three backup referees for the first time.

Two games, two stadiums, about 110 miles

Willard, a side judge in his ninth season, refereed Dolphins at Colts in Indianapolis at 1 p.m. ET (8 p.m. Cairo). Indianapolis won 24-22 after Miami’s two-point try with 14:56 left failed. Aditi Kinkhabwala reported that his crew threw 16 accepted flags in a game that ran 3 hours and 13 minutes, and that Willard “ran a clean ship with good communication.” Thirteen of the 16 were on the Colts.

Willard, umpire Terry Killens, field judge Jabir Walker and side judge Justin Larrew then drove to Cincinnati. John Breech reported that Willard left Lucas Oil Stadium at 4:44 p.m. ET and reached Paycor Stadium at about 6:35 p.m., 105 minutes before he handled the Steelers-Bengals coin toss. Brooke Pryor reported that the crew got off the van at 6:37 p.m. and went straight into the usual 90-minute pregame meeting. The other three officials on the night crew were fresh.

The night game was quieter. Willard’s crew called 12 accepted penalties, eight on Cincinnati and four on Pittsburgh, as Joe Burrow threw for four touchdowns in a 38-18 Bengals win. That made 28 accepted penalties for Willard’s crews in one day. “It’s never been done before, as far as we know,” Terry McAulay, the rules analyst on the Sunday night broadcast, said of the doubleheader. Jonathan Jones reported on Sunday that, according to league records, no official had refereed two games in one day since at least 1970.

A Carolina record in the game with remote replay

Panthers at Saints was the busiest game of the day for the flags. Umpire Duane Heydt, one of the three backup referees, worked it with a crew that had no replay official on site, so every review was handled from New York. Carolina was penalized 17 times for 152 yards, and New Orleans three times for 46. Joe Person noted that after the Saints’ go-ahead touchdown with 3:49 left, the Panthers’ 16 penalties had already tied their franchise record and their 137 penalty yards had broken it. The 17th came on the Saints’ last drive.

The game ended with three plays involving officials. With 1:55 left, Chuba Hubbard was ruled down at the 1-yard line, and the replay review from New York upheld it. Hubbard scored on the next play for a 17-14 lead. A 15-yard face mask penalty on Carolina linebacker Tyrel Dodson then helped set up Charlie Smyth’s 55-yard field goal that tied it with 41 seconds left. On the Panthers’ final drive, a 30-yard pass interference call on Saints cornerback Kool-Aid McKinstry, only New Orleans’ third penalty of the game, moved Carolina into range for Ryan Fitzgerald’s 54-yard field goal as time expired.

Carolina is the 13th road team in NFL history to win while being penalized 17 or more times, Person reported, and the second in the last 10 seasons. The Panthers are now the league’s most-penalized team, with 87 accepted penalties for 787 yards in nine games.

Every Sunday game, by referee

The other two backup referees had quiet days. Barry Anderson’s crew called seven accepted penalties in the Jaguars’ 40-23 win at Tennessee. In Las Vegas, Bill Vinovich’s crew called two, both on Seattle, and the Raiders became the first team this season to go through a game without an accepted penalty. These are accepted penalties from the box scores, so declined and offsetting flags are not counted.

GameRefereeAccepted penalties (yards)Total
Patriots vs. Lions (Munich)Clay MartinNE 7 (45), DET 7 (75)14
Chiefs at FalconsAlan EckKC 7 (61), ATL 9 (65)16
Texans at BrownsShawn SmithHOU 13 (112), CLE 2 (47)15
Vikings at PackersClete BlakemanMIN 7 (75), GB 6 (45)13
Dolphins at ColtsDon Willard (backup)MIA 3 (30), IND 13 (83)16
Panthers at SaintsDuane Heydt (backup)CAR 17 (152), NO 3 (46)20
Bills at JetsRon TorbertBUF 7 (35), NYJ 7 (53)14
Jaguars at TitansBarry Anderson (backup)JAX 2 (20), TEN 5 (27)7
Rams at CardinalsLand ClarkLAR 5 (15), ARI 4 (20)9
Seahawks at RaidersBill VinovichSEA 2 (15), LV 0 (0)2
49ers at CowboysJohn HusseySF 11 (100), DAL 5 (35)16
Steelers at BengalsDon Willard (backup)PIT 4 (46), CIN 8 (80)12

The 12 Sunday games averaged 12.8 accepted penalties, below the season average of 14.5 per game. Seahawks-Raiders, with two, was the least-penalized game of the season. That fits what Roger Goodell said in Munich on Sunday morning, when he defended the league’s officials and their use of technology, although his figures included all flags thrown, not only accepted penalties.

The reshuffle is not over. Adrian Hill, who swapped games with Land Clark, referees the Chargers at the Ravens on Monday night (3:15 a.m. Tuesday, Cairo). The league office reviews every game during the week, and the Week 10 fines, which last week came to a season-low 19, will be announced on Saturday.

The why matters.

See something that needs a second look? Read our corrections policy.

Join the conversation

Use a name or stay anonymous. No account or email required. Comments are reviewed before appearing.

Up to 3,000 characters

No published comments yet. Start the conversation.