Bill Belichick and Tom Brady at a Patriots practice in August 2009

whynfl.

November 15, 2009: Bill Belichick goes for it on fourth-and-2 from his own 28, and Peyton Manning’s Colts beat the Patriots 35-34

whynfl.

Fourth-and-2 at his own 28

On November 15, 2009, the Patriots led the unbeaten Colts 34-28 with 2:08 left in Indianapolis. They faced fourth-and-2 at their own 28. The conventional call was to punt. Bill Belichick kept his offense on the field.

whynfl.

A yard short

Tom Brady threw to Kevin Faulk, who juggled the ball and was driven back by safety Melvin Bullitt. The officials spotted it at the New England 29, just short of the marker. With no timeouts left, Belichick could not challenge the spot.

whynfl.

Manning finishes it

Peyton Manning took over 29 yards from the end zone. Four plays later he threw the winning touchdown to Reggie Wayne on a slant Wayne had asked for, with 13 seconds left. The Colts won 35-34.

whynfl.

From 31-14 down

New England had led 31-14 early in the fourth quarter. Manning answered with touchdown drives to Pierre Garcon and Joseph Addai before the final one. Brady threw for 375 yards and three touchdowns, and Randy Moss caught nine passes for 179 yards.

whynfl.

“That was a yard”

“That was a yard I was confident we could get,” Belichick said. It was the first time his Patriots had lost a game they led by at least 13 points in the fourth quarter. The Colts went on to win their first 14 games.

Image credit

Bill Belichick and Tom Brady at a Patriots practice in August 2009, three months before the fourth-and-2 call in Indianapolis. Photo by Andrew Choy, CC-BY-2.0, cropped and resized

whynfl.

The full picture.

Read the complete article for more detail and the latest updates.